The Visa Strip: A Last-Minute Shock
Just days ago, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke abruptly cancelled the visa of Simcha Rothman—a member of the Israeli Knesset—who was due to visit and speak to Jewish community groups. The surprising rationale: his condemnation of Hamas might “upset” Australia’s Muslim community. This wasn't just bad optics; the Australian Jewish Association called it a “viciously antisemitic move” and warned Jewish community members that they are now feeling unwelcome.
Recognition of Palestine: Diplomatic Detonation
But the visa drama was just the spark. On August 11, 2025, the government announced it would recognise a Palestinian state—even before a peace deal—deepening a rift with Israel. The reaction was fierce: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accused Albanese of betraying Israel and “abandoning Australia’s Jews,” calling him “weak” and claiming his reputation is now irreversibly tarnished.
Diplomatic Tit-for-Tat Escalates
Israel didn’t hold back. In retaliation, it revoked visas for Australian diplomats assigned to the Palestinian Authority, signalling a severe diplomatic strain.
Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong slammed the backlash as “unjustified,” asserting that dialogue—not confrontation—is the path forward toward peace.
Jewish Australians Feeling Forsaken
This isn’t just diplomacy missteps—it’s real anxiety in the Jewish community. The sudden visa cancellation isn't isolated; it follows previous denials for prominent Israeli figures. The pattern, Jewish leaders say, has been disheartening—and dangerous.
What It All Signals
-
Mismanaged Diplomacy? Opposition voices are already accusing the government of bungling a traditional alliance and compromising national credibility.
-
Jewish Community at Risk? Labels of favouritism toward one group over another aren’t just words—they carry real consequences for safety and societal cohesion.
-
Diplomatic Fallout: Strained ties could jeopardise bilateral cooperation in security, economy, research, and more.
Bottom Line
Australia’s shift from a steadfast Israeli ally to a political pivot toward Palestinian recognition signals a recalibration of foreign policy—but at what cost? Jewish Australians warn the government’s moves feel hostile, not just policy-driven. With diplomatic tensions multiplying, it's a fragile time to abandon long-standing alliances. The government needs to urgently engage with Jewish communities—not silence them.
Here is a recent video with Chris Kenny and Alex Ryvchin of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry highlighting the concerns of the Jewish Community.
