Welcome

Welcome to Grappy's Soap Box - a platform for insightful commentary on politics, media, free speech, climate change, and more, focusing on Australia, the USA, and global perspectives.

Friday, 13 November 2026

Doomsday again? I’ve already put the kettle on.



Today is Friday the 13th of November 2026. If you’re reading this over breakfast, so far so good. In 1960, three researchers published a paper in Science with today’s date in the title. Their equation said the human population would approach infinity if it kept growing the way it had over the previous two millennia. The word if was right there in the subtitle. Amazing how much work two letters can do, and how easily they fall out of a headline. 

1910 — Halley’s Comet was going to poison us. Newspapers reported that French astronomer Camille Flammarion thought gas in the comet’s tail could wipe out life on Earth. The Earth passed through the tail. Halley’s Comet has since been back for another visit. We seem to be getting along better these days. 

The 1970s — Better buy a warmer coat. In 1971, two scientists calculated that a fourfold increase in airborne particles could cool the planet enough to trigger an ice age. In 1975, Newsweek warned that global cooling could send food production into a steep decline within ten years. World cereal production rose over that decade. A later review found 44 papers from 1965 to 1979 projecting warming and seven projecting cooling. Guess which ones made for a better story about the end of civilisation. 

The 1980s — Even the rain was out to get us. Acid rain was damaging lakes and forests. The US tightened power-plant pollution rules under its 1990 Clean Air Act amendments. The EPA later measured a 71 per cent drop in the amount of sulphate deposited by rain and snow across the eastern US, comparing 2000–02 with 2019–21. Apparently you can fix quite a lot at the smokestack. It just makes for a less dramatic picture than a forest full of dead trees. 

1985 — A hole in the sky. British scientists found that the ozone layer was thinning dramatically over Antarctica. Countries agreed to phase out CFCs and other ozone-depleting chemicals under the 1987 Montreal Protocol. The ozone layer is recovering, though the Antarctic is expected to take until around 2066 to return to 1980 levels. If you were hoping for a quick repair, bear in mind the job is over Antarctica and the tradesman has to bring his own ladder. 

2000 — British children were going to forget what snow was. The Independent ran the headline “Snowfalls are now just a thing of the past” after a researcher said winter snow would become rare within a few years. A decade later, widespread snow accompanied the UK’s coldest December in a century. A good month to be in the sled business. 

2009 — The Arctic was going to run out of summer ice. At Copenhagen, Al Gore cited a 75 per cent chance of an ice-free Arctic summer within five to seven years. At its September minimum in 2016, the Arctic still had 4.14 million square kilometres of sea ice. Low by historical standards. Quite a lot by the standards of an empty ice tray. 

2011 — The apocalypse got a second booking. American radio preacher Harold Camping said Judgment Day would come on 21 May. When May came and went, he moved it to October. You have to admire the confidence of a man who can reschedule the end of the world. 

There’s a meme going around about 50 years of failed climate predictions. The Competitive Enterprise Institute’s roundup covers half a century of environmental headlines, from ice-age scares to population and warming claims. Flick through it and you can see why the memes practically write themselves. 



Doomsday sells. Sometimes we act on a real problem and things improve. Sometimes a headline gets ahead of the evidence. Either way, a date in bold type can make a guess look like an appointment. Next time someone tells me the end is nigh, I’ll read the bit after if. Then I’ll put the kettle on.


Thursday, 12 November 2026

Cost of Living: Perception or Reality?


Nearly nine in ten voters in the US midterm exit polls said the cost of living was a major factor in their vote. Many said they felt worse off than when Donald Trump returned to the White House. As I wrote after the election, losing both houses of Congress was a serious defeat. But the cost-of-living explanation raises a question I wanted to test. Were people actually losing purchasing power? (Reuters on the exit polls , Trump Lost Congress. Did His Achievements Get Lost Too?)

I expected the numbers to show that prices had outrun wages in most places. In the eight metropolitan areas I checked, the opposite happened. Average hourly pay kept ahead of prices in six. Only in New York and Philadelphia did the average private-sector wage buy less than it did two years earlier.

Metro area

Prices rose

Average hourly pay rose

What an hour’s pay could buy

Phoenix

3.9%

9.4%

5.3% more

Houston

2.4%

6.4%

3.9% more

Dallas–Fort Worth

5.0%

7.4%

2.3% more

San Diego

8.8%

10.5%

1.6% more

Chicago

5.9%

6.7%

0.8% more

Los Angeles

7.3%

7.8%

0.4% more

Philadelphia

7.6%

5.9%

1.6% less

New York

7.6%

5.1%

2.4% less

Two-year changes to August or September 2026, depending on when each metro publishes its CPI. Sources include the US Bureau of Labor Statistics metro CPI and BLS hourly earnings via FRED.

San Diego surprised me most. It had the biggest price rise of the eight. If you looked at prices alone, you might assume it had suffered the biggest squeeze. Yet average pay there rose faster still. Philadelphia had a smaller price rise, but wages lagged. An hour’s work bought more in San Diego than it had two years earlier and less in Philadelphia.

So why might someone in San Diego still feel worse off? Think about what you see at the supermarket. You remember what a bag of groceries used to cost. You see the new price every week. A pay rise arrives separately, and some of it may already be spoken for by the time it lands. If your rent jumped or your hours were cut, your own budget might well have gone backwards. A metro average can tell us how the typical basket moved against average hourly pay. Your bills tell you how you fared.

There’s also a question of where you start counting. I compared late 2026 with late 2024. A voter remembering what groceries cost before the pandemic is making a different comparison. Two years of modest gains in purchasing power can coexist with a lasting sense that everyday life has become expensive.

The exit polls tell us that affordability mattered to voters. The wage figures tell us that a broad loss of purchasing power is a poor fit for what happened in most of the places I checked. 

But it’s a gap worth taking seriously. If average pay bought more in six of the eight places I checked, why did so many voters feel they were going backwards? Perhaps the political damage came as much from the perceptions about high costs. Perceptions that were created by concerted reporting about high costs without mention of commensurate increases in wages. No doubt such negative perceptions were amplified by partisan politics, which worked well for the Democrats and were not countered by Republicans. Irrespective of the cause, it appears, admittedly from my limited analysis, that during Trump's second term increases in cost of living were more than offset by increases in wages. 

Of course perceptions have consequences.

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Thorium Reactors: From Promise to Prototype

 


Eleven years after I first wrote about thorium, a Danish company is turning an extraordinary nuclear idea into real machinery. Could this be the breakthrough we've been waiting for?

Back in 2015, I wrote a post titled What the Heck Is Thorium?.

I was intrigued by the possibility that thorium could overcome some of the biggest objections to conventional nuclear power: safety, radioactive waste, fuel availability and cost.

I returned to the subject in my 2017 Thorium Nuclear Update.

The promise was enormous. But there was always one rather inconvenient problem.

Nobody had managed to turn that promise into an economically viable commercial power station.

Now, nearly a decade later, a Danish company called Copenhagen Atomics may be getting us considerably closer.

I recently watched a fascinating video examining its technology, including a visit to the company's workshops and a detailed explanation of the engineering problems it has been tackling.

What impressed me was not another grand prediction about nuclear energy. It was the machinery, the prototypes and the practical solutions being developed.

For the first time in years, I think thorium deserves another serious look.

Why thorium was so exciting in the first place

Thorium is a naturally occurring radioactive element, roughly three times as abundant in the Earth's crust as uranium.

It has extraordinary energy potential.

But thorium has a peculiar characteristic: it cannot directly sustain the nuclear chain reaction used to produce electricity.

Instead, thorium-232 must absorb a neutron and undergo a series of transformations to become uranium-233, which is an excellent nuclear fuel.

That means a suitably designed reactor can potentially manufacture much of its own fuel while operating.

Imagine a power station that starts with a modest quantity of conventional nuclear fuel, then gradually produces the fuel it needs from a plentiful material that might otherwise be discarded as a mining byproduct.

That is the attraction of a thorium breeder reactor.

And unlike conventional nuclear plants, which generally use solid uranium fuel rods and highly pressurised water, thorium can be used in a molten-salt reactor operating at relatively low pressure.

The potential advantages are substantial:

  • Safety: Low-pressure operation and passive shutdown systems can reduce certain accident risks.

  • Fuel efficiency: A successful breeder could extract far more energy from its fuel resources.

  • Waste: The thorium fuel cycle offers opportunities to reduce some long-lived radioactive waste, although it cannot eliminate radioactive waste.

  • Abundance: Thorium is widely available, including as a byproduct of rare-earth mining.

  • Cost: Compact, factory-manufactured reactors could avoid some of the enormous construction costs associated with conventional nuclear projects.

The physics has been understood for decades.

The difficulty has always been making the engineering work reliably and economically.

Enter Copenhagen Atomics

Copenhagen Atomics was founded in 2014 and has spent more than a decade developing a compact molten-salt reactor.

Its proposed commercial unit is designed to produce 100 megawatts of thermal energy, equivalent to approximately 42 megawatts of electricity when connected to suitable generating equipment.

The reactor module itself is designed around the dimensions of a standard shipping container.

That is a remarkable departure from the huge, individually constructed nuclear power stations we are accustomed to seeing.

The company calls its reactor design the Onion Core.

The name comes from its concentric layers, each performing a different function.

At the centre is a molten-salt fuel channel where nuclear fission produces heat and neutrons.

Surrounding it are layers of heavy water that slow the neutrons, helping maintain the chain reaction.

An outer blanket containing thorium captures other neutrons, gradually converting thorium into uranium-233.

The cleverness lies in making the most of every neutron.

A reactor must produce enough neutrons to maintain its own operation while also converting thorium into replacement fuel.

Lose too many neutrons to the surrounding structure or unwanted chemical reactions, and the breeding process fails.

Copenhagen Atomics has designed its geometry around this problem.

The company hopes eventually to develop reactors that can sustain themselves predominantly through thorium breeding.

There is an important qualification: its first planned commercial reactors will still require low-enriched uranium. The company describes them as approaching fuel self-sufficiency rather than achieving full breeding from the outset.

That is an intermediate step, but potentially an important one.

Solving the problems that defeated earlier attempts

The most interesting part of the video concerns two engineering challenges that have frustrated molten-salt reactor developers for decades.

First, corrosion.

Molten fluoride salts operate at temperatures around 600°C or higher. Unfortunately, impurities in those salts can attack the metal containing them.

Earlier researchers addressed this problem by developing specialised nickel-based alloys, including Hastelloy N.

These materials work, but they are expensive and introduce additional complications.

Copenhagen Atomics has taken a different approach.

Rather than relying entirely on exotic metals, it has developed methods of purifying the molten salts to extremely high standards.

The company reports that ordinary stainless steel exposed to its purified salts showed minimal corrosion after 3,000 hours of testing.

If those results hold up over years of operation inside an actual nuclear reactor, the implications for manufacturing costs could be substantial.

Second, the lithium problem.

The molten salts contain lithium, but not all lithium atoms behave alike.

Lithium-7 is useful because it absorbs relatively few neutrons.

Lithium-6, however, absorbs neutrons readily, robbing the reactor of particles needed to sustain the reaction and breed new fuel.

For a thorium breeder, that can be fatal to the economics of the design.

Copenhagen Atomics has therefore been developing highly enriched lithium-7 for its reactor salts.

These may sound like obscure technical details.

But they are precisely the kinds of problems that separate an attractive scientific theory from a commercially useful machine.

And that is why this project interests me.

A different approach to nuclear safety

Another important feature is the reactor's proposed passive safety system.

In a conventional light-water reactor, the combination of high pressure, hot water and the need for continuous cooling creates particular engineering challenges.

Copenhagen Atomics proposes a low-pressure molten-salt system in which a serious loss of power or pumping capability would cause the fuel salt to drain by gravity into specially designed tanks.

There, the nuclear chain reaction would stop and the material could cool.

This does not make the reactor risk-free. Radioactive materials still require containment, shielding and long-term management.

But it potentially eliminates some of the accident mechanisms associated with conventional reactors.

The company also plans to replace the reactor's internal module approximately every five years, retaining the valuable fuel salts for reuse.

Rather than attempting to make every component last for decades, the idea is to manufacture replaceable units economically.

It is an interesting engineering philosophy: make the reactor compact, standardised and serviceable.

Could nuclear power really become this cheap?

Here is where the story becomes particularly interesting.

Copenhagen Atomics is proposing a price of approximately US$50 million for each 100-megawatt thermal reactor module, plus an annual fuel and maintenance fee of around US$2 million.

Its target cost for the nuclear heat and reactor service is approximately US$10 per megawatt-hour.

Once electricity generation equipment, site costs and other infrastructure are included, the company is targeting approximately US$30–40 per megawatt-hour of electricity.

If achieved, that would be competitive with many established forms of electricity generation and dramatically cheaper than numerous recent conventional nuclear projects.

It could also provide reliable electricity around the clock, without depending on sunshine or wind.

But these figures are targets based on the company's engineering and commercial models.

They are not yet prices demonstrated by an operating commercial power station.

The real test will come when the technology operates continuously, meets regulatory requirements and can be manufactured repeatedly at the predicted cost.

Still, the possibility is sufficiently important that it deserves serious attention.

The next test is in Switzerland

Copenhagen Atomics has built two full-scale non-nuclear prototypes, with a third under development. The next milestone is nuclear testing through the BALDER project, in collaboration with Switzerland's Paul Scherrer Institute.

Initial testing is now expected no earlier than 2028, with commercial reactors targeted for the early 2030s.

These are ambitious timelines, and significant engineering and regulatory hurdles remain. But this is no longer simply a theoretical exercise.

What about Australia?

Australia has substantial thorium resources and an obvious interest in reliable, affordable, low-emission electricity.

Our nuclear debate tends to focus on conventional reactors and today's costs. Yet the technology is evolving.

If Copenhagen Atomics delivers on its promises, compact thorium reactors could change that debate considerably.

We should not commit to unproven technology. Equally, we should not make fifty-year energy decisions assuming that today's technology is the last word.

Is thorium's moment finally arriving?

When I first wrote about thorium in 2015, the promise was extraordinary. The engineering wasn't ready.

Eleven years later, Copenhagen Atomics has made tangible progress towards solving some of the problems that held it back.

There is still no commercially proven thorium breeder reactor. But if the Danish team succeeds, we could see a new generation of compact, safer and potentially much cheaper nuclear power.

After more than half a century of promises, thorium may finally be moving from scientific possibility to commercial reality.

That is a development worth watching.

Grappy


Further reading and viewing

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Weekly Roundup - Top Articles and Commentary from Week 46 of 2026


      

Here are links to some selected articles of interest and our posts from this week.


Cartoon of the Day







We welcome all feedback; please feel free to submit your comments or contact me via email at grappysb@gmail.com or on X at @grappysb

How Much Can We Trust AI?




Ask an AI chatbot about a war, an election or a scientific controversy and it will give you a neat answer in seconds. The sentences are clear. The tone is calm. It sounds as though someone has weighed the evidence and reached a considered conclusion.

But what if the chatbot has simply inherited somebody else’s version of events?

The edit war you never see

In January, I wrote about the risk of Wikipedia’s editorial biases finding their way into AI. A recent piece from HonestReporting brings that question closer to home. What happens when a dispute over the wording of a Wikipedia article becomes part of the answer a chatbot gives you today? 

HonestReporting points to a Toronto event advertised as a “Free Palestine Wiki Edit-a-Thon.” Organisers offered to train participants to edit Wikipedia and then work together on articles. There is nothing inherently wrong with teaching people to edit an encyclopedia. But when an event is organised around an explicit political cause, it’s fair to ask how the resulting edits will be checked for balance. 

Wikipedia has already had to referee disputes over articles on Israel and the Palestinians. In January 2025, its Arbitration Committee barred eight editors from working on the topic. Reporting at the time identified six as pro-Palestinian and two as pro-Israel. The bans show that Wikipedia has a way to deal with disruptive editing. They also show how fiercely people fight over what goes into an encyclopedia many readers take at face value. 

How the bias travels

There are two ways a source can influence an AI answer. Its text can be part of the material the model learned from during training. Or an AI tool with web access can find the page when you ask your question and use it to compose a response. HonestReporting’s piece highlights that second route. It gives us reason to scrutinise the answers, although tracing any one answer to a particular edit takes more evidence. 

An outright falsehood is often the easiest problem to spot. Framing is harder. Which event gets the first paragraph? Whose account is presented as fact and whose is introduced as a claim? What happened the day before, and did it make it into the summary? Every sentence can be defensible on its own while the overall account leaves a misleading impression.

On Wikipedia, a curious reader can look at the footnotes, the editing history and the arguments on the discussion page. A chatbot can compress all of that into three tidy paragraphs. Unless you follow the links, you may never know there was an argument in the first place.

So how much should we trust it?

I use AI and will keep using it. It’s a quick way to get oriented on an unfamiliar subject. But on a disputed question, I want to see where the answer came from. If three citations all lead back to the same original claim, I’ve still got one source. And if the chatbot gives me a conclusion I’m already inclined to believe, that’s an especially good time to open the links.

The Israel example should concern us whatever our politics. The same mechanism can carry someone’s preferred account of an election, a public health controversy or a government’s record. The more people rely on a single answer, the more it matters who shaped the sources behind it.

The next time AI gives you a confident answer on a question people are still fighting over, ask it one more question. What evidence would make you change that answer? Then see whether the evidence it gives you is worth trusting.

Further reading

Friday, 6 November 2026

Trump Lost Congress. Did His Achievements Get Lost Too?




The Republicans have lost Congress. That's a serious defeat. But is the political reaction proportionate, and why have some significant achievements received so little attention?

The American midterm elections have produced a decisive victory for the Democrats. They have taken control of both the House of Representatives and the Senate, seriously restricting Donald Trump's ability to pursue his legislative agenda.

The headlines have been dramatic. A blue wave. A repudiation of Trump. A president whose second term is already in trouble.

There is no disguising the result. Losing both houses of Congress is a substantial political setback.

But before accepting the prevailing interpretation, two questions deserve attention.

How unusual is this result historically? And why does the discussion of Trump's failures so often overshadow any examination of what his administration has actually achieved?

First, put the result into perspective

American presidents have a long history of suffering setbacks in midterm elections. The president's party has lost House seats in 18 of the previous 20 midterms.

Consider the record:



The 2026 House result is therefore substantial, but not unprecedented. The gains reported so far are smaller than the losses suffered by Clinton in 1994, Obama in 2010 or Trump himself in 2018. The final comparison must await completion of the count.

The Senate tells a more serious story. Democrats have flipped at least seven Republican-held seats and taken control of the chamber. That is a significant shift, particularly given the states in which they won.

Losing both houses matters. It changes the balance of power in Washington and gives Democrats the ability to block legislation and pursue investigations.

But historical perspective matters too.

A midterm defeat does not automatically mean that a presidency has failed, any more than a midterm victory guarantees future success.

What about Trump's achievements?

Much of the post-election discussion has focused on Trump's personality, his controversial statements, the Iran war and the cost of living.

Those are legitimate subjects.

But a serious assessment of his administration should also consider its record.

Border security. The reduction in illegal crossings at the southern border has been dramatic. Government figures show a substantial decline in apprehensions. Whatever one's views about immigration enforcement, the reduction is a significant policy outcome.

Crime. FBI figures show that violent crime fell sharply in 2025, including a substantial decline in murder. The downward trend began before Trump's return to office, so he cannot claim all the credit. Nevertheless, the continuing improvement is an important development that deserves attention.

Government efficiency. The administration has challenged federal spending, cancelled contracts and pursued alleged waste and fraud. Its Department of Government Efficiency has claimed substantial savings. 

China, Iran and Venezuela. Trump has pursued a confrontational approach toward governments he regards as strategic adversaries. His supporters point to increased pressure and efforts to constrain their influence. 

These are not insignificant areas of government policy.

Yet they have often struggled to compete for attention with Trump's latest controversy.

The economy: Trump inherited the prices, not just the inflation

Perhaps the most misunderstood issue in this election has been the cost of living.

Victor Davis Hanson has pointed to a striking comparison. Inflation reached 9.1% during Biden's presidency, compared with 3.7% in September 2026. Gasoline prices were also exceptionally high in 2022.

But there is a distinction that seems to be missing from much of the political discussion.

Reducing inflation does not reduce prices. It merely slows the rate at which they increase.

Suppose groceries cost $100 before the inflationary surge. After a 20% increase, they cost $120. Reduce inflation to 3%, and the following year they cost $123.60.

The inflation rate has fallen dramatically. Yet the family is still paying nearly 24% more than before.

Those accumulated price increases do not disappear when a new president takes office.

And this is where Trump's economic record needs to be considered more carefully.

The high inflation of the Biden years left American households with a substantially higher cost base. Even if inflation subsequently moderates, wages must grow faster than prices over a sustained period before purchasing power fully recovers.

Recent figures show that this recovery remains incomplete. Nominal wages have increased, but inflation has absorbed much of those gains.

Trump also bears responsibility for developments during his own presidency. Tariffs and the Iran war have contributed to renewed price pressures, particularly for fuel.

Nevertheless, blaming today's entire cost-of-living problem on the current administration ignores the cumulative effect of earlier inflation.

Voters remember what things used to cost. Economists measure how quickly prices are changing. They are not asking quite the same question.

The political problem is that voters do not experience inflation as an annual percentage. They experience it at the supermarket checkout and petrol pump.

A president may be able to slow inflation relatively quickly. Restoring the purchasing power lost over several years is a much longer undertaking.

And there is little electoral reward for explaining that distinction to someone who is still struggling to pay the bills.

Trump is often his own worst enemy

There is another explanation for why achievements may receive less attention than Trump expects.

Trump has an extraordinary ability to dominate the news. Unfortunately for him, he does not always dominate it in ways that help his own cause.

His confrontational style, personal attacks, extravagant claims and repeated threats generate enormous coverage.

Critics regard this as evidence of poor judgement. Supporters often see it as a willingness to challenge established political conventions.

Either way, it has consequences.

Consider Iran.

The administration's military campaign and diplomatic pressure deserve assessment against their strategic objectives. But Trump's repeated public threats have also created expectations that are difficult to satisfy.

When a president announces dramatic consequences and those consequences do not immediately follow, the discussion shifts from what has been achieved to whether the president has lost credibility.

The announcement becomes the story, rather than the outcome.

Would Trump have been better served by saying less, allowing his administration's actions to speak for themselves and announcing results only when they were achieved?

We cannot know whether that would have changed the election.

But it is reasonable to wonder whether a more disciplined public presentation would have made it easier for voters to judge his record.

Is Trump judged by a different standard?

Trump has been a polarising figure since entering national politics.

Some of that hostility reflects genuine disagreements over policy, democratic institutions and presidential conduct. Some reflects his own deliberate provocations.

But there is also a broader question about the way political narratives develop.

Once a politician becomes defined primarily by controversy, even significant policy achievements can struggle to receive sustained attention.

Conversely, every mistake becomes further evidence supporting an established interpretation.

Trump's relationship with much of the American media has been openly adversarial for years. The coverage frequently applies standards that are not applied equally to other politicians.

There is also a generational dimension. Younger voters encounter politics through universities, social media and cultural institutions, where attitudes toward Trump can be particularly negative. 

It raises the question whether voters are receiving a sufficiently complete account of what governments do, rather than a continuous negative account of what politicians say.

Trump's administration should be judged on its actual results—including failures—not simply on its president's latest remarks.

A defeat, not a final verdict

The Republicans have suffered a real defeat. Losing both houses of Congress is consequential, and the Democrats have every reason to regard the result as a significant electoral success.

The electorate has also sent a message about affordability, economic confidence and the direction of the administration.

But midterm elections are not final judgments on presidencies.

History shows that presidents can suffer substantial congressional losses without those losses defining their entire record.

Trump has delivered measurable changes in some areas, made contested claims in others, and created political difficulties through his own conduct.

Perhaps the most interesting lesson is that a president can dominate the political conversation so completely that his personality overshadows his policies—even when those policies have had measurable success.

That may be Trump's greatest political strength.

And, as these midterms suggest, one of his greatest weaknesses.



Monday, 2 November 2026

Weekly Roundup - Top Articles and Commentary from Week 45 of 2026

      

Here are links to some selected articles of interest and our posts from this week.
Cartoon of the Day





We welcome all feedback; please feel free to submit your comments or contact me via email at grappysb@gmail.com or on X at @grappysb



Justice Delayed, Accountability Denied




When Governments Delay, Victims Pay, And accountability quietly disappears.

When a government makes a serious mistake, who pays?

Usually, the victims.

And when the government takes twenty or thirty years to acknowledge that mistake, the victims pay again.

They pay through years of uncertainty, legal battles, financial hardship and the frustration of being told that their suffering has not yet been officially recognised.

By the time the government finally apologises, many of those responsible have retired, the politicians have moved on, and some of the victims are dead.

Delay doesn't just postpone justice. It can destroy the possibility of accountability.

COVID: Another inquiry, but where is the accountability?

A recent video by Dr John Campbell examines a British parliamentary debate on 27 October 2026 about the government's response to the UK COVID-19 Inquiry.

During the pandemic, governments exercised extraordinary powers. They confined people to their homes, closed businesses, disrupted education, restricted travel and family contact, and imposed vaccination requirements on sections of the population.

Some emergency measures were justified. Others remain disputed. But the damage caused by restrictions was real, and the decisions deserve rigorous scrutiny.

COVID vaccines reduced the risk of severe illness, particularly among vulnerable people. They also caused rare but sometimes serious adverse reactions. Those recognised injuries deserve proper compensation.

Britain established a major public inquiry in 2022. Its report on vaccines and therapeutics was published in April 2026.

The Inquiry recommended reforming the Vaccine Damage Payment Scheme. The government responded in October, acknowledging the need for reform but without committing to the recommended changes or a timetable.

Meanwhile, injured people continue to wait.

This is the problem with inquiries that identify failures but leave the consequences to another department, another review or another government.

An inquiry is not accountability. Accountability requires action.

We've seen this before. Again and again.

Campbell's video reminded me how frequently serious institutional failures have followed the same depressing pattern.

First comes the harm. Then denial, resistance or delay. Eventually an inquiry establishes the facts. Years later, there may be an apology or compensation.

By then, the people who made the decisions are often long gone.

Here are examples from Britain, Australia, Canada and the United States.



These cases are not identical. Some involved government decisions, others failures of regulation, corporate misconduct or official secrecy. The dates also distinguish different milestones—recognition, disclosure, apology and compensation are not the same thing.

But the recurring problem is unmistakable.

The institutions responsible for addressing the harm can take years or decades to deliver justice.

Consider the British infected blood scandal. Thousands were infected through contaminated blood products. In 2024, the British Prime Minister finally delivered a comprehensive apology.

Or Hillsborough, where families fought for 23 years before an independent panel exposed the extent of the failures and misleading official accounts.

Or Australia's Robodebt scandal, where people were pursued for debts calculated using an unlawful method before the programme was dismantled and a Royal Commission exposed what had gone wrong.

The victims were expected to comply with government decisions immediately.

The government, however, could take years to accept responsibility.

Delay is not neutral

We tend to treat delays in government inquiries as unfortunate administrative problems.

But delay has consequences—and those consequences are not shared equally.

For the victim, every additional year may mean another year without compensation, another year of legal expenses, another year of illness or financial distress.

For the institution, time can be an advantage.

Public attention fades. Documents become harder to locate. Witnesses die. Ministers retire. Officials move to other jobs.

Eventually, responsibility becomes so dispersed that nobody is held personally accountable.

The government may apologise. Taxpayers may fund compensation. But the individuals whose decisions caused the damage may suffer no consequences at all.

The taxpayer pays for the original failure, pays for the inquiry, and then pays the compensation.

The people responsible may pay nothing.

That is a perverse incentive.

What must change?

We cannot punish governments for every decision that turns out badly. Emergencies involve uncertainty, and honest mistakes are inevitable.

But serious failures demand more than an apology delivered decades later.

When credible evidence of major government wrongdoing or negligence emerges, there should be a prompt, independent investigation with the power to obtain documents and identify who made the relevant decisions.

Victims should have access to timely compensation without being forced into years of expensive litigation.

Inquiry recommendations should have deadlines, publicly identified responsible officials and regular progress reports.

And where serious negligence, deliberate concealment or misconduct is established, those responsible should face appropriate professional, civil or criminal consequences.

Responsibility should not evaporate simply because someone acted on behalf of the government.

Justice delayed is accountability denied

The lesson from these scandals is not that governments must never make mistakes.

It is that governments must not be allowed to escape responsibility by taking decades to acknowledge them.

The COVID pandemic provides another opportunity to test whether we have learned that lesson.

We need to know which decisions were justified, which caused avoidable harm, who made them and what consequences should follow.

We also need to ensure that people genuinely harmed by government policies are not left fighting for recognition until it is too late.

History shows what happens when governments are allowed to delay.

Victims grow old. Some die. The responsible officials disappear into retirement. Eventually a new government offers an apology and sends the bill to taxpayers.

That is not accountability. It is accountability by attrition.

And unless we change the system, the next government failure will follow exactly the same path.